Grounding media freedom in the EU: The legal basis of the EMFA
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32091/RIID0209Keywords:
EMFA, Media Pluralism, Media Freedom, Harmonisation, Legal BasisAbstract
The article critically examines the choice of Article 114 TFEU as the legal basis for the European Media Freedom Act (EMFA), which aims to harmonise media regulation across Member States to support media freedom and pluralism. The study, firstly, identifies two contrasting perspectives (critics and supporters of the chosen legal basis) and, secondly, highlights two shortcomings of the EMFA (its focus on market-based solutions risks commodifying freedom of expression and its ex-ante regulatory framework). Despite these concerns, the author argues that the EMFA represents a constitutional evolution for the EU, bridging old and new media paradigms to ensure democratic values and the integrity of the digital market. The conclusion argues that the broad interpretation of Article 114 TFEU is justified and in line with the EU's role in safeguarding democracy and fundamental rights and signalling the new direction of EU integration. However, the success of the EMFA will depend on its effective implementation and the capacity of EU institutions to ensure freedom of expression, fair competition and robust regulation in the digital age.
References
J. Bayer (2024-a), Digital Media Regulation within the European Union, Nomos, 2024
J. Bayer (2024-b), Legal implications of using generative AI in the media, in “Information & Communications Technology Law”, vol. 33, 2024, n. 3
R. Böttner, H.-J. Blanke (2024), Article 114 [Harmonisation in the Internal Market], in A. Engel, X. Groussot, G.T. Petursson (eds.), “Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union - A Commentary”, vol. II, Springer, 2024
E. Brogi (2024), EMFA Under the Spotlight: Towards a Common Regulatory Framework to Foster Media Pluralism? Introduction, in “Rivista italiana di informatica e diritto”, 2024, n. 2
E. Brogi, D. Borges, R. Carlini et al. (2023), The European Media Freedom Act: media freedom, freedom of expression and pluralism, European Union: European Parliament; Policy Department for Citizens’ Rights and Constitutional Affairs; Directorate-General for Internal Policies, 2023
E. Brogi, P.L. Parcu (2014), Evolving regulation for media freedom and pluralism in the European Union, in “Utilities Policy”, vol. 31, 2014
M. Cantero Gamito (2023), The European Media Freedom Act (EMFA) as Meta-regulation, in “Computer Law & Security Review”, vol. 48, 2023
M.D. Cole (2024), Acting on Media Freedom: The Proposed European Media Freedom Act (EMFA) of the European Union, in “University of the Pacific Law Review”, 2024, n. 2
M.D. Cole, C. Etteldorf (2023-a), Future Regulation of Cross-border Audiovisual Content Dissemination: A Critical Analysis of the Current Regulatory Framework for Law Enforcement Under the EU Audiovisual Media Services Directive and the Proposal for a European Media Freedom Act, Nomos, 2023
M.D. Cole, C. Etteldorf (2023-b), Research for CULT Committee - European Media Freedom Act. Background Analysis, European Parliament, Policy Department for Structural and Cohesion Policies, 2023
M.D. Cole, C. Etteldorf (eds.) (2021), On the Allocation of Competences between the European Union and its Member States in the Media Sector, Nomos, 2021
K. Cseres (2024), European competition law, an overlooked element of the EU’s rule of law toolbox, Swedish Institute for European Policy Studies: Sieps 23epa, November 2024
B. Custers (2022), New digital rights: Imagining additional fundamental rights for the digital era, in “Computer Law & Security Review”, vol. 44, 2022
B. de Witte (2017), Exclusive member state competences: is there such a thing?, in S. Garben, I. Govaere (eds.), “The division of competences between the EU and the member states: reflections on the past, the present and the future”, Hart, 2017
F. Donati (2022), Unione europea, libertà e pluralismo dei mezzi di informazione nella proposta di Media Freedom Act, in “Medialaws”, 2022, n. 2
G. Doyle (2002), Media ownership: The Economics and Politics of Convergence and Concentration in the UK and European Media, SAGE, 2002
A. Engel (2023), The Choice of Legal Basis in EU Competition Law: Shifting the Competence in the Digital Era, in “Europarättslig tidskrift”, 2023, n. 4
A. Engel, X. Groussot (2024), Making the Rule of Law Great Again: The Building of the Digital Rule of Law in the European Union, in A. Engel, X. Groussot, G.T. Petursson (eds.), “New Directions in Digitalisation: Perspectives from EU Competition Law and the Charter of Fundamental Rights”, Springer, 2024
C. Etteldorf (2023), Why the Words “But” and “However” Determine the EMFA’s Legal Basis, in “Verfassungsblog on matters constitutional”, 13 June 2023
European Commission (2024), 2024 Rule of Law Report, 2024
European Commission (2020), European Democracy Action Plan: making EU democracies stronger, 3 December 2020
European Commission (2007), Media Pluralism in the Member States of the European Union, Commission Staff Working Document SEC(2007) 32, 16 January 2007
E. Fahey (2022), The EU as a Global Digital Actor: Institutionalising Global Data Protection, Trade, and Cybersecurity, Hart, 2022
E. Fahey, S. Poli (2022), The strengthening of European technological sovereignty and its legal bases in the Treaties, in “Eurojus.it”, 2022, n. 2
M.L. Flear (2017), Regulating New Technologies: EU Internal Market Law, Risk, and Socio-Technical Order, in M. Cremona (ed.), “New technologies and EU law”, Oxford University Press, 2017
J. Franck, G. Monti, A. de Streel (2021), Art. 114 TFEU as a Legal Basis for Strengthened Control of Acquisitions by Digital Gatekeepers, Legal Opinion commissioned by the (German) Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy, 20 September 2021
A.J. Garcia Pires (2017), Media pluralism and competition, in “European Journal of Law and Economics”, vol. 43, 2017, n. 2
O. Grandinetti (2024), Quale nozione di pluralismo nell’EMFA?, in “Rivista italiana di informatica e diritto”, 2024, n. 2
C. Holtz-Bacha (2024), Freedom of the media, pluralism, and transparency. European media policy on new paths?, in “European Journal of Communication”, vol. 39, 2024, n. 1
T. Kerševan (2024), Dalla retorica alla regolamentazione: EMFA e la concentrazione dei media nell’era digitale, in “Rivista italiana di informatica e diritto”, 2024, n. 2
A. Koltay (2024), Media Freedom and the Law: The Regulation of a Common European Idea, Taylor & Francis, 2024
V. Kosta (2015), Fundamental rights in EU internal market legislation, Hart, 2015
M. Kozak (2024), The Media Pluralism Principle, The Financing of Public Broadcasters, and EU Law, in “German Law Journal”, vol. 25, 2024, n. 1
L. Malferrari (2023), Der European Media Freedom Act als intra-vires-Rechtsakt, in “EuZW–Europäische Zeitschrift für Wirtschaftsrecht”, 2023, n. 2
A. Manganelli (2023), Piattaforme digitali e social network, fra pluralità degli ordinamenti, pluralismo informativo e potere di mercato, in “Giurisprudenza costituzionale”, 2023, n. 2
A. Manganelli, A. Nicita (2022), Regulating Digital Markets: The European Approach, Springer, 2022
R. Mastroianni (2022), Freedom and pluralism of the media: an European value waiting to be discovered?, in Aa. Vv., “Le droit européen, source de droits, source du droit. Etudes en l’honneur de Vassilios Skouris”, Mare & Martin, 2022
R. Mastroianni (2013), Competenze normative dell’Unione europea e disciplina del pluralismo informativo: regolamentazione o concorrenza nel settore audiovisivo?, in R. Pisillo Mazzeschi, A. Del Vecchio, M. Manetti, P. Pustorino (eds.), “Il diritto al pluralismo dell’informazione in Europa e in Italia”, Rai Eri, 2013
R. Mastroianni (2011), La direttiva sui servizi di media audiovisivi e la sua attuazione nell’ordinamento italiano, Giappichelli, 2011
M. Monti (2024), Towards a Federal-Type Regulation of Online Public Discourse by the EU?, in “European public law”, vol. 30, 2024, n. 4
P.-C. Müller-Graff, (2024), Strategic Sovereignty – Aspects of Its Legal Dimension, in G. Barrett, P.-C. Müller-Graff, J.-P. Rageade, V. Vadász (eds.), “European Sovereignty: The Legal Dimension”, Springer, 2024
B. Nascimbene, F. Rossi dal Pozzo (2023), L’evoluzione dei diritti e delle libertà fondamentali nel settore dei media. Diritto dell’Unione europea, orientamenti giurisprudenziali e recenti interventi normativi, in “Eurojus.it”, 2023, n. 1
A. Nicita (2024), Il mercato delle verità: come la disinformazione minaccia la democrazia, il Mulino, 2024
F. Paolucci (2023), The European Media Freedom Act: (another) new chapter in the digital regulation saga, in “Diritti Comparati”, 6 maggio 2024
V. Papakonstantinou, P. De Hert (2022), The Regulation of Digital Technologies in the EU: The law-making phenomena of “act-ification”, “GDPR mimesis” and “EU law brutality”, in “Technology and Regulation Journal”, 2022, n. 1
P.L. Parcu (2020), New digital threats to media pluralism in the information age, in “Competition and Regulation in Network Industries”, vol. 21, 2020, n. 2
P.L. Parcu, E. Brogi (2021), Introduction, in P.L. Parcu, E. Brogi (eds.), “Research handbook on EU media law and policy”, Edward Elgar Publishing, 2021
P.L. Parcu, M.A. Rossi (2021), Policy Changes to Strengthen the Protection of Media Freedom and Media Pluralism in the EU, in P.L. Parcu, E. Brogi (eds.), “Research handbook on EU media law and policy”, Edward Elgar Publishing, 2021
R. Schütze (2014), Limits to the Union’s ‘Internal Market’ Competence(s), in L. Azoulai (ed.), “The Question of Competence in the European Union”, Oxford University Press, 2014
R.C. Smith (2004), Rethinking European Union competence in the field of media ownership: The internal market, fundamental rights and European citizenship, in T. Gibbons (ed.), “Regulating Audiovisual Services”, Routledge, 2004
G. Strozzi (2013), Libertà d’informazione e pluralismo nell’ordinamento dell’Unione europea, in R. Pisillo Mazzeschi, A. Del Vecchio et al. (eds.), “Il diritto al pluralismo dell’informazione in Europa e in Italia”, RaiEri, 2013
D. Tambini (2021), Media freedom, Polity Press, 2021
P. Valcke, R.G. Picard, C.D. Zotto et al. (2015), Indicators for media pluralism, in P. Valcke, M. Sükösd, R.G. Picard (eds.), “Media pluralism and diversity: Concepts, risks and global trends”, Palgrave, 2015
V. Vīķe-Freiberga, H. Däubler-Gmelin, B. Hammersley, L.M. Poiares Pessoa Maduro (2013), A free and pluralistic media to sustain European democracy, January 2013
S. Weatherill (2016), The internal market as a legal concept, Oxford University Press, 2016
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Rivista italiana di informatica e diritto
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
rivistariidATigsg.cnr.it